1998 WWLPT Biology Institute:  Motion

ANTS IN MOTION!

National Standards Addressed
       Life Science (Content Standard C)
            Behavior of organisms
            Diversity and adaptations of organisms
            Interdependence of organisms
        Science as Inquiry (Teaching Standard A, Content Standard A (5-8, 9-12))
            Abilities related to scientific inquiry
            Understanding about scientific inquiry
 
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract
Instructor's Objectives
Target Age or Ability Group Audience
Notes to The Teacher
Materials & Equipment Needs
Background [Prior Knowledge or vocabulary necessary to complete activity]
The Student Lab
Evaluation Rubric
Extension/Reinforcement/Additional Ideas
References
Glossary of Terms

 



Abstract  to top

     Ant feeding habits are wide and varied. ANTS IN MOTION explores these varied habits with experimentation and activities appropriate for a wide range of grade levels. The investigative, hands-on approach is inquiry-based and is in line with National Science Educational Standards.

KEYWORDS:  ants, NSES, inquiry, insects, animal behavior, constructivist lab
 to top



Instructor's Objectives to top
After completing this activity, students will be able to apply the scientific method in creating and investigating a problem

*  Effectively use the scientific method
*  Maintain a group of living organisms
*  Observe aspects of ant behavior and anatomy.
*  Design experiments with control groups, dependent, and independent variables.
*  Create extension investigations from their results.
 
to top



Target Audience or Age Group  to top
Environmental and Life Science
    Designed for high school, but can be modified for any age level.  For a middle school extended project on ant behavior, click here.  There are also many linked sites that would be applicable to elementary students.
 to top


 Notes to the Teacher: to top Phase 1 - Beginning the Constructivist Model:  Engagement
    Since ants are one of the most prevalent organisms on earth, they are inherently interesting to students in all areas of the United States, and indeed, the world.  Almost all students have had some experience with ants, but that experience may be limited to spraying a colony with RAID.  Teachers can introduce the activity by drawing on that common experience with ants.  In addition, there are stories and upcoming movies that prominently feature ants.  Since students will be constructing their own experiments, it is imperative that the instructor first leads students in a brainstorming session.  This will provide students with an opportunity to listen and participate in the creation of several of their own questions.  It also provides the instructor with an opportunity to assess the knowledge of individual students.  This knowledge may be useful in the creation of student investigation teams.

Useful Pre-Lab Discussion Questions:

 
Assign students to groups of 2 or 3 and have them write down and answer selected questions with their group.  These questions may be debriefed in a class discussion.  The questions that they are unable to answer can be turned into good research projects and/or experimental investigations.

Phase 2  - Creating a Hypothesis
At this point in the investigation, it is beneficial for students to make careful observations of ant behavior.  The ants may be brought into the classroom in ant farms or other containers that allow for easy observation.  Students are also encouraged to take some time and observe ants in their natural environment.

Ant farms may be constructed from the directions in the materials section.  Each ant farm will be large enough to house 30 small to medium ants (between 4-6 mm).  Most student groups will need 5 to 10 ants for their investigations.  After the ant farms are up and running, it is good to have the students do research and revisit the original pre-lab questions, adding more questions and answers to the list.  There are many different types of ant farms depending on material availability, research needs, and cost.   Here are a few ant farm links.

Split the class into project teams and ask them to choose one question to investigate from the list of questions the class has generated.  It should be a question that they think that they can answer by using a scientific experiment.  Encourage students to choose a wide variety of questions and let them know that they may change their minds once they have begun to learn some things about ants.  Once students have chosen a question, allow them time to research the answer to that question.  This research can be done independently as a homework assignment or with explicit teacher guidance, depending on the class and the research experience of the students.  After they have some basic knowledge, help students form a hypothesis for their question.

Click HERE for an example of a hypothesis.
 

Phase 3 - Experimental Design:  Testing the Hypothesis
    At this point, student groups should have a problem, have done some research and have a well designed hypothesis.  This is the time for the students to create their experimental designs to test their hypotheses.  There are several lead-ins that may help students create a step-by-step procedure for their experiments (extra activities link).  Be sure to have students write out a detailed experimental design in their work groups.  Students will need to understand specific concepts such as control group, independent variables and dependent variables.  Make sure that the groups include a control in their experimental design and are realistic about the materials that they will need to complete their investigation.  WARNING!!  Ants have a mind of their own, so students must develop experiments based on behaviors they have already observed.  It is suggested that students investigate the ants in their own environment.

The instructor needs to guide and approve experimental designs.
 
Click HERE for an example of an experimental design.
 
Phase 4- The Experiment
Trouble shoot the student performance of the experiments.  Encourage students to modify rather than give up.

Phase 5- Recording, reporting and analyzing results
Guide students in creation of  tables and graphs. Allow students time to analyze data.

Click HERE for an example of a data table and graph.
  
Phase 6- Discussion and conclusions
Students should explain how data supported or refuted their hypothesis. Teachers should encourage their students to develop alternative conclusions from their results and discuss sources of error.

Click HERE for an example of a possible discussion and conclusion.

Phase 7: Lab Report

Students may include the following parts in their laboratory reports:

Click HERE for a sample student lab report

to top



Materials & Equipment Needs to top

It is suggested that the students have an ant farm in the classroom in order to observe ant behavior.  Materials and Equipment for student group experiments will vary.
 
to top



Background to top

It is important that the teacher has some basic background knowledge in these areas before beginning this unit.

A. The scientific method

B.  Insects - click for background information

C. Ants - click any of the following for ant background information

to top


The Student Lab to top
Name:  ______________________________                Date:  ________________________

ANT BEHAVIOR LAB

Have you ever seen ants on the sidewalk?  Have you ever seen ants in your house?  Have you ever had ants in your pants?  How did these ants know exactly where the food was?  How did they know where you put your favorite Halloween Candy?

In this lab, you have the opportunity to CHOOSE your OWN QUESTION to explore about that most familiar and lovable of insects, the ANT!!!!

PHASE 1.  WHAT DO YOU KNOW?
Before we get started, let's see what you know about these critters.

With your partner(s), choose 8 questions from the following list to answer about ants, their relatives, and their behavior.  Add two original questions to answer created by your group.

to top

PHASE 2  - Creating a Hypothesis   to top

Pick up an ant farm from the supply area.
Carefully observe the behavior of the ants in the ant farm/container.

Add information you learn from your observations to your answers from Phase 1.

In your project team, choose one (1) question to investigate from the class list of possible questions.  Focus on one question at a time.

WRITE YOUR QUESTION HERE:

_____________________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________

From your question/problem statement, write a possible answer to the question (i.e., a HYPOTHESIS).

WRITE YOUR HYPOTHESIS HERE:

_____________________________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________
 

PHASE 3 - Designing the experiment and testing the Hypothesis
 

What is the independent variable for your experiment?

____________________________________________________________________________________

What in the dependent variable for your experiment?

____________________________________________________________________________________

What are the other variables that need to be controlled in your experiment?

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

Briefly describe your control group set up.

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________
 

Create an experiment  to test your hypothesis.  Provide details of that experimental design below.

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

List the materials that you will need.

____________________________________________________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________________________

Show the design and materials list to your teacher before performing the investigation.

Teacher signature to continue ___________
to top

 PHASE 4:  Do experiment

If you encounter difficulties,  modify the experiment and continue on.

PHASE 5: Record, report and analyze results
 
Create a table to record your ants' activities.

If applicable, create a graph comparing your results of the experimental  group versus your control group. Write a summary statement for each table/graph.
 

PHASE 6: Discussion and conclusions

Explain the data collected. Did data support or refute your hypothesis? Why or why not?
What other factors may have affected the results? Explain three (3) ways to improve your experimental design.

PHASE 7: Lab Report

Include the following parts in your laboratory report:

Click HERE for a sample student lab report
to top


Rubric/Assessment to top
 
 
SUPERIOR
SATISFACTORY
NEEDS IMPROVEMENT
NEEDS TO BE RESUBMITTED
Performance demonstrates a thorough understanding of the use of  scientific methods to solve problems.
Performance demonstrates a basic understanding of the use of  scientific methods to solve problems.
Performance demonstrates limited understanding of the use of  scientific methods to solve problems.
Performance demonstrates minimal understanding of the use of  scientific methods to solve problems.
Hypotheses are null, testable, consistent with observations, relate to the problem under consideration, and attempt to control the important experimental variables.
Hypotheses are testable, consistent with observations, relate to the problem under consideration, with adequate control of experimental variables.
Hypotheses may be untestable, though related to the problem, or show inadequate control of experimental variables. 
Hypotheses do not relate to the problem under consideration.
Observations, measurements, and calculations are precise and accurate.
Observations, measurements, and calculations are generally correct.
Observations may  be incomplete, and/or measurements may be inaccurate.
Observations and/or measurements are faulty.
Appropriate technologies are selected for gathering and analyzing data.
The data are represented in accepted scientific format including graphs and tables where appropriate.
Data are represented in graphs and tables that may contain some errors or omissions.
Data are displayed, but the organization is not apparent.
Conclusions are based on the data and may include analogies, or connections to real-world issues.  Conclusion attempts to explain anomalous findings or data.
Conclusions are based on the data.  Scientific facts, principles, laws, and concepts are appropriately applied with only minor errors or omissions.
Conclusions are based on data, but analysis of the data may be inaccurate.  Scientific principles, laws and concepts are recognized, but may be applied inaccurately.
Conclusions are unsubstantiated by the data.  There is little evidence that appropriate scientific laws, principles or concepts have been applied.
Written expression is clear and concise and may include diagrams.
Written expression is clear, and may include diagrams.
Written expression contains some errors that limit effective communication.
Written expression contains errors that limit effective communication.
** from Instructional Services 12/96.  "Science #4  Processes of Science"

to top



Extension/Reinforcement/Additional Ideas to top

Some interesting quotes about ants:
The insects make up more than 99% of all animal species.

[T]he ants . . . range 20,000 or more species strong from the arctic circle to the tip of South America.  In the Amazon rain forest they compose more than 10 percent of the biomass of all the animals.  This means that if you were to collect, dry out, and weigh every animal in a piece of forest, from monkeys and birds down to mites and roundworms, at least 10 percent would consist of these insects alone. Ants make up almost half of the insect biomass overall and 70 percent of the individual insects found in the treetops.,  They are only slightly less abundant in grasslands, deserts, and temperate forests throughout the rest of the world. (Wilson, E.O., 1992, p.5)

Workers foraging around their nest are not merely insects searching for food.  They are a living web cast out by the superorganism, ready to congeal over rich food finds or shrink back from the most formidable enemies.  Superorganisms can control and dominate the ground and treetops in competition with ordinary, solitary organisms, and that is surely why ants live everywhere. (Wilson, E.O., 1992, p.6)
 

to top 



References Including Web Addresses to top
 
The following web sites are helpful for providing background information for the teacher and students. The following books are helpful in providing background information for the teacher and students.
This page was created and is maintained by these high school biology teachers:
 
Ruth Baldivia Denver, CO
Ian Bleakney Oakland, CA
Janice Chen Glen Head, NY
Robert Furtado Austin, TX
 
Click on a name to email comments or questions
.
 
 

Glossary of terms:
1. Arthropods - paired jointed appendages.

2. Control Group - Controlled experiments are designed to study cause and effect.  There must be a standard to which the experimental data can be compared.  A control group is free of any change - free on the independent variable.

3.  Controlled Variable - Only the independent variable is changed in an experiment.  All other factors must be kept constant and are called "Controlled Variables."

4. Dependent Variable - You change one factor to observe what will happen to something else.  That "something else" is the Dependent Variable, or the effect.  What are you observing as an effect in this experiment?

5. Hymenoptera - a homometabolous group (complete metamorphosis), no legs on the larval form, exarate pupal form ( free legs) and a cocoon. 2 pair of membranous swings, hind wings smaller than the forewings.

6. Hypothesis - Lets say your group has a certain idea about how water temperature will affect the goldfish's respiratory rate. Formulating a hypothesis allow you to test that idea.  A hypothesis is usually written in the form of an "if___then___" statement so it can be tested.  Writing the hypothesis in this form allows you to identify the variable you want to purposely cause to vary and the effect you want to observe.

7. Independent Variable - In science experiments, you often vary one factor to observe what will happen.  The factor you vary is called the Independent Variable.

8. Insect - Any organism that has 3 body sections, 3 pairs of legs and/or wings.

9. Mandibles - Jaw structures (mouth parts) www.icaen.uiowa.edu/~djtack/ant.html

10. Pheromones - chemical messages secreted by organisms as a form of communications i.e.. food finding, mate finding.

11. Stridulation - sounds made by an ant rubbing body parts together, act as a form of communication

12. Theory - a hypothesis supported by experimental evidence.
 

 Back to the top